Agency or DIY

Marketing agency vs doing your own marketing as a trade business

Doing your own marketing is often the right call when you are starting out, your diary is mostly word of mouth and you have evenings to learn. An agency starts to make sense when paid ads, SEO and a website need steady expert attention you cannot give without taking time off the tools. Unavoidable Marketing is a UK-wide, Leeds-based agency that runs marketing for trades across the UK, and founder Andrew Heppinstall is on every strategy call.

Book a free 30-minute strategy call

Last updated: 21 October 2026

An honest starting point

We are an agency, so you might expect us to say you need one. You might not. Plenty of trades run busy, profitable firms on a good Google Business Profile, steady reviews and a phone that rings from past customers. If that is you, spending money on an agency may not change much.

The question is not “agency or DIY” in general. It is which jobs in your marketing you can do well yourself, which ones you are doing badly or not at all, and what that is costing you in missed enquiries or wasted ad spend.

It also helps to count your own time properly. An evening spent learning Google Ads settings is an evening not spent quoting, doing the books or with your family. For a sole trader in a quiet month, that trade can be worth it. For a firm with a full diary and staff to manage, the same hours are often better spent elsewhere. Neither answer is wrong. It just needs to be a choice you make on purpose rather than by default.

Side by side

What matters Doing it yourself Using an agency
Your time Evenings and weekends Short check-ins and approvals
Cash outlay Lower, mainly ad spend and tools Agency fee plus ad spend
Knowledge of your trade You know it best Depends on the agency
Google Ads skill Learn as you go Should be day-to-day work
Consistency Slips when you are busy Carries on when you are busy
Control Total Shared, you should keep ownership
Risk Costly mistakes while learning Paying for a poor agency
Speed of getting set up As fast as you can learn Depends on the agency’s process
Tracking and reporting Often skipped or basic Should be set up from day one
What happens if you stop Marketing stops when you do You keep your accounts if you own them
Best suited to New and word-of-mouth firms Firms ready to grow steadily

What most trades can do well themselves

Some marketing jobs reward knowing your customers more than knowing marketing. These are often better done by you, or at least with you.

  • Asking every happy customer for a Google review, and replying to every review.
  • Adding real job photos to your Google Business Profile: the finished bathroom in Norwich, the new consumer unit in Swansea.
  • Posting short job videos and before and after photos on Facebook and Instagram.
  • Answering calls quickly and calling back missed ones the same day.
  • Keeping your business name, address and phone number the same everywhere.
  • Telling customers what you do and do not take on, including any legal limits such as Gas Safe work.

None of those need an agency. They need a habit.

Where DIY tends to go wrong

The jobs that trip trades up are the technical ones where mistakes cost money quietly.

Google Ads is the big one. Left on broad settings, a campaign for a roofer in Bristol can spend on “roofing jobs”, “how to fix a roof yourself” and towns an hour away. Without negative keywords, call tracking and conversion tracking set up properly, you cannot tell which clicks became booked jobs. Google’s own recommendations are designed to help you spend, not always to help you profit.

Websites are the second. Template sites with stock photos, slow pages on a phone, no tap-to-call button and a domain registered in someone else’s name all lose enquiries you never hear about. SEO is the third: it takes months of consistent work, and that is exactly what slips when the diary fills up.

Tracking is the quiet fourth. Lots of trades running their own marketing cannot say which source brought which job. Without that, every decision is a guess: you keep paying for something that is not working, or you switch off something that was. Even a simple record of every enquiry, where it came from and whether it booked, puts you ahead of most.

When an agency makes sense

An agency earns its fee when it gives you back time and turns spend into booked jobs more reliably than you could alone. That usually means:

  • You want to run Google Ads or Local Services Ads properly and do not have the hours to learn and manage them.
  • You are hiring or adding vans and need a steadier flow of the right enquiries.
  • Your website is not bringing in work and you want it rebuilt to rank in the towns you cover.
  • You want to show up in AI search tools like ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews, which reward consistent, well-structured information across your site and other trusted sources.
  • You have tried DIY, kept it going for a while, and know where it is falling short.

How to spot a good agency, and a bad one

A good agency for trades talks about booked jobs and enquiries, not clicks, impressions or likes. Ad spend should be paid straight to Google or Meta on your own card, so you can see every penny and nothing is marked up. You should own your ad accounts, your website and your domain, so you can leave with everything. Look for short or no contracts, plain reporting and someone senior who understands your trade.

Be wary of guaranteed rankings, promises of being “number one”, long lock-in contracts, or an agency that will not give you access to your own accounts. Nobody can guarantee a position on Google or a mention by an AI assistant.

A worked example: two electricians

Picture an electrician in Swansea who has been self-employed for a couple of years. Most work comes from past customers and builders they know. They have a verified Google Business Profile with steady reviews, a simple website they built themselves, and they post finished consumer units and EV chargers on Facebook now and then. Their diary is mostly full.

For them, an agency would probably add cost without adding much. The better move is to tighten what they already do: ask every customer for a Google review that names the job and the town, add photos after every job, make sure the website has tap-to-call and shows their NICEIC or NAPIT registration, and keep their business details the same everywhere. That is DIY done well, and it suits them.

Now picture an electrical firm in Bristol with several vans and an apprentice starting soon. Word of mouth is no longer enough to keep everyone busy, and the owner tried Google Ads for a few months but could not tell which calls came from it. The website is old and the domain is registered to a web designer who no longer replies.

Here, outside help is likely to pay for itself if it is the right help. The firm needs the domain moved into its own name, a site with proper service and area pages, Google Ads campaigns split by job type with negative keywords and call tracking, perhaps Local Services Ads, and reporting on booked jobs. The owner keeps doing the reviews and photos, because nobody knows the customers better. The agency does the technical work.

The same thinking applies to a plumber in Norwich or a roofer in Glasgow. Look at what you are good at, what is slipping, and what it costs you.

How to decide: questions to ask yourself

  • How many hours a week can I realistically give to marketing, every week, including busy months?
  • Do I know where my last batch of booked jobs came from?
  • Am I running paid ads now, and can I see which clicks or calls became work?
  • Is my website bringing in enquiries, and do I own the domain and the login?
  • Do I need more work, different work, or work in new towns?
  • Have I got the capacity to handle more enquiries if they come?
  • Which marketing jobs do I enjoy and do well, and which do I keep putting off?
  • If I hired help, what would I measure it on after a few months?

If your answers show you are busy, tracking well and growing as you want, carry on. If they show gaps you keep meaning to fix, that is where help, from an agency, a freelancer or a one-off set-up, can be worth paying for.

Common mistakes to avoid

When doing it yourself

  • Letting Google’s automatic recommendations widen your ads without checking what they do.
  • Running ads with no call tracking or conversion tracking.
  • Stopping reviews, photos and posts the moment the diary gets busy.
  • Building a website on a template with stock photos and no tap-to-call.
  • Copying what a competitor does without knowing whether it works for them.

When hiring an agency

  • Signing a long contract before you have seen any results.
  • Letting the agency open ad accounts or register the domain in its own name.
  • Accepting reports full of clicks and impressions with nothing about booked jobs.
  • Handing over everything, including reviews and customer replies that you do best.
  • Not telling the agency which jobs you want more of and which you would rather avoid.

Getting started with each route

Getting started on your own

  • Claim and complete your Google Business Profile, with the right primary category, services and photos.
  • Set up a simple way to ask every happy customer for a Google review.
  • Make sure your website is fast on a phone, has tap-to-call and shows your accreditations.
  • Start a simple record of every enquiry, where it came from and whether it booked.
  • If you try Google Ads, start small and tight: one job type, a tight area, negative keywords and call tracking.
  • Book a regular slot each week for marketing and protect it.

Getting started with an agency

  • Write down what you want: more of which jobs, in which towns, and how many you can handle.
  • Speak to a few agencies and ask how they measure success and who you will speak to.
  • Check contract terms, who owns the accounts and how ad spend is paid.
  • Keep your domain, website, ad accounts and Google profile in your own name.
  • Agree how you will track enquiries and booked jobs before anything goes live.
  • Review results together regularly and be ready to change course.

The middle route

It does not have to be all or nothing. Many trades keep the bits they are good at, such as reviews, photos and social posts, and hand over the technical work like Google Ads, website and SEO. Others pay for a one-off set-up and audit, then run things themselves. If you go DIY, a free check of your website or ad account can show where the gaps are before you spend more.

Which should you choose?

Do it yourself if

You are new or mostly busy from word of mouth, have time to learn, and your main needs are reviews, a good Google profile and some social posts.

Use an agency if

You want paid ads, SEO and a website working together, your time is better spent on jobs, and you want results measured in booked work.

Mix the two if

You enjoy the customer-facing side and want help only with the technical work like ad accounts, tracking and the website.

Wait if

Your diary is already full for months ahead. Fix pricing, capacity or hiring first, then grow the marketing.

How we do it

Flat monthly fee

Quoted after a free call.

  • Google Ads, Local Services Ads, SEO, website and social, chosen to fit your trade.
  • Ad spend paid straight to Google or Meta on your own card, never marked up.
  • You own your accounts, website and domain.
  • Measured on booked jobs and enquiries, not clicks or likes.
  • Plain reporting and Andrew Heppinstall on every strategy call.
  • No contract, rolling 30-day terms.

Book a free 30-minute strategy call

Frequently asked questions

Should a trade business use a marketing agency or do its own marketing?

It depends on your stage and your time. DIY suits new and word-of-mouth firms that can keep up reviews, a strong Google profile and social posts, while an agency suits firms ready to grow through paid ads, SEO and a better website. Unavoidable Marketing is a UK-wide, Leeds-based agency for trades, and we will tell you on a free call if DIY is the better fit.

Can I run Google Ads myself as a tradesperson?

Yes, many do. Keep it tight: search campaigns split by job type, negative keywords, a service area you actually cover, call tracking and conversion tracking so you can see which clicks became booked jobs.

What should I keep in my own name if I use an agency?

Your domain, your website, your Google Ads and Meta ad accounts, your Google Business Profile and your analytics. If you ever leave, you should take all of it with you.

How long should I give an agency before judging it?

Paid ads can show whether they bring booked jobs within a few weeks once tracking is right. SEO builds over months, so judge it on steady progress in enquiries rather than instant results.

Is it worth paying an agency for a one-off set-up?

It can be. A proper set-up of tracking, campaigns and your Google profile, followed by you running things day to day, suits trades who are hands-on but short on technical know-how.

What are the warning signs of a bad agency?

Guaranteed rankings, long lock-in contracts, marked-up ad spend, reports full of clicks but no booked jobs, and refusing to give you access to your own accounts.

How much time does DIY marketing take for a trade business?

It depends on what you take on. Reviews, photos and occasional posts can fit into a few minutes a day, while running Google Ads and SEO properly takes regular, focused hours every week, including when you are busy.

Should I hire a freelancer instead of an agency?

A good freelancer can suit a trade that needs one thing done well, such as a website or a Google Ads set-up. Apply the same checks as for an agency: you own the accounts and domain, ad spend is on your card, and results are measured in booked jobs.

Can I go back to doing my own marketing after using an agency?

Yes, as long as your domain, website, ad accounts and Google profile are in your own name. That is why ownership matters from the start, whichever route you choose.

Ask us about this for your trade business

Send a quick message and Andrew will come back to you, usually the same working day.

    Talk to Andrew about your trade business

    Book your free strategy call

    Ready when you are

    Let's make you unavoidable.

    Book a free strategy call: no pressure, just a clear plan for getting found, called and booked.

    Businesses we’ve helped grow

    Fusion Trampoline ParkAshton Service CentreRichmond Fitness ClubNatural BalanceProdog RawBeesafe SuppliesFulwood London
    See our case studies →

    Ready to get to the top of Google for your trade?

    We set up, verify and manage your Local Service Ads: you only pay per genuine lead. Book a free eligibility check and weโ€™ll show you whatโ€™s possible in your area.

    Book your free eligibility check โ†’

    Not sure what Local Service Ads could return?

    Estimate your leads, jobs and revenue in seconds with our free calculator.

    Try the free LSA ROI calculator →
    Call now Get a free quote